Hi Karen,
The Davis House was built by Eli Davis your GG Uncle, a son of George Davis and Ann Jacobs. It is still in the family, beautifully restored and occupied. See
www.heritage.nf.ca/articles/society/davis-house.php for more on the Davis House.
I am aware of the George Davis Merchant but have not yet made a connection.
Your George Davis 1807-1882 was the son of William and Jane Davis. They had 6 children George, Richard, Alfred, William, Francis, and Amelia.
I have photos of George and Ann Davis's headstones in Freshwater. I have recorded 542 descendants of George Davis including you and myself (your 3rd cousin). George was married 3 times 1) Patience ? (one child) 2) Jane Pottle (No children) and 3) Ann Jacobs (12 children) including your great grandfather Joseph and my great grandmother Sarah Lilias.
There were many members of the Freshwater Davis Family that moved to Mass. My father's 1st cousin (90 yrs old on Aug 1-2015) was home for a visit last month. He has lived in Concord, MA for many years, and has been back home many times.
Peter Davis